Selling Candidate Names On T-Shirts: Legal Or Not?

Whether or not you can sell t-shirts with a candidate's name on them is a complex legal issue. In the US, the First Amendment protects your right to express support for a political candidate through original designs and artwork. However, using a candidate's name or likeness for commercial purposes without their consent may violate their right of publicity. This is especially true if you create a false association with the candidate or their campaign. To avoid legal issues, it is essential to consult a lawyer and ensure you have the candidate's consent before selling any merchandise with their name or likeness. Additionally, be cautious when using images or artwork, as these may be protected by copyright laws, and always ensure you have the necessary permissions or are using content that is in the public domain.

Political candidates' names on t-shirts may be protected under the 1st Amendment

The First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution guarantees freedom of speech and expression, which generally protects the right to use political candidates' names on t-shirts. However, it is important to note that this does not permit the use of a candidate's name, image, or likeness to create a false association with them or their campaign. The right to free speech must be balanced with the individual's right to publicity and privacy.

In the case of Minnesota Voters Alliance v. Mansky, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that electioneering laws prohibiting voters from wearing political apparel at polling places violate the First Amendment when they lack clear and objective standards for enforcement. This ruling suggests that laws restricting political expression, such as wearing or selling t-shirts with political candidates' names, may be subject to constitutional challenges if they infringe on free speech rights.

It is generally legal to use the names of politicians and candidates on t-shirts without their permission, as they are considered public figures. However, using their likeness, such as photographs, without consent may violate their "publicity rights," especially if used for commercial purposes. It is advisable to consult with a lawyer before proceeding with any specific plans to ensure compliance with applicable laws and to respect the rights of individuals and election groups.

While the First Amendment provides a strong defence for using political candidates' names on t-shirts, it is important to be mindful of potential legal risks. Some candidates have been known to sue over unauthorised use of their names or likenesses, so obtaining consent from the candidate or their campaign may be a prudent step to avoid legal issues.

Permission is required to use a politician's name or likeness for commercial purposes

When it comes to using a politician's name or likeness for commercial purposes, it is important to understand that permission is typically required. The use of a person's name or likeness without their consent can violate their "publicity" rights, and this applies especially to politicians. While the First Amendment protects free speech and expression, it is crucial to balance it with the rights of publicity and privacy.

In the United States, the right of publicity is a legal concept that grants individuals control over the commercial use of their name, likeness, or other aspects of their identity. This right protects individuals, including politicians, from having their name or likeness exploited for commercial gain without their consent. It is important to note that the right of publicity varies from state to state, and some states, like Tennessee, have stronger protections in place.

It is worth noting that the definition of a "public figure" may come into play in this context. According to one source, a public figure is "an individual who has assumed roles of especial prominence in the affairs of a society or thrust themselves into the forefront of particular public controversies to influence the resolution of the issues involved." This suggests that individuals running for political office may be considered public figures, even before they are elected.

However, there are some exceptions and nuances to consider. For example, if the politician is a candidate, there may be specific rules or regulations that apply during election campaigns. Additionally, the specific design and context of the T-shirt design are important factors. Using original artwork or designs that are in the public domain can help avoid potential legal issues. Fair use laws may also come into play, but they can be complex and subject to interpretation.

In conclusion, while there may be some gray areas and exceptions, it is generally advisable to seek permission from a politician before using their name or likeness for commercial purposes, especially if the intention is to sell merchandise. Consulting with a lawyer who specializes in intellectual property or publicity rights can provide more specific guidance on an individual's rights and responsibilities in this area.

Using a public figure's name without consent violates their right of publicity

The right of publicity is an individual's right to control the commercial use of their image, name, and likeness, and to prevent unauthorised uses of these. This right is protected by law in many states, though the specifics of the law vary between them.

In the US, the right of publicity is a state law issue, with only about half of states recognising it. In these states, the right is found in statutes governing the right to privacy or under laws prohibiting unfair competition. For example, California prohibits people from using "another's name, voice, signature, photograph, or likeness, in any manner, on or in products, merchandise, or goods, or for purposes of advertising or selling, or soliciting purchases of, products, merchandise, goods or services." New York has a similar statute, though it is based on privacy rights, so the right does not pass to an individual's estate after their death.

The right of publicity can be violated if someone's name or likeness is used without their consent for an exploitative purpose, such as advertising. This is distinct from defamation, which involves false statements that damage a person's reputation.

Using a public figure's name or likeness without their consent for commercial purposes can violate their right of publicity. This includes selling merchandise with their name or likeness, as this implies that the individual endorses the product. However, the right of publicity must be balanced with First Amendment rights. For example, using a caricature of a public figure is likely to be protected by the First Amendment, as it includes a significant degree of original expression.

It is important to note that consent is an absolute defence to a claim of right of publicity infringement. Therefore, it is advisable to obtain permission before using a public figure's name or likeness for commercial purposes.

Using original designs can help avoid copyright issues when selling t-shirts with candidates' names

When it comes to selling t-shirts with the names of political candidates, it's important to navigate the legal landscape to avoid any copyright issues. Using original designs can be a strategic way to mitigate these risks. Here's how:

First and foremost, it's essential to understand the concept of public domain. Works in the public domain are no longer protected by intellectual property laws, and anyone can use them without seeking permission. This includes artworks whose copyright has expired, such as Vincent Van Gogh's Self-Portrait with a Straw Hat (1887), which was released into the public domain by the Met in 2017. Public domain images can be sourced from websites like Wikimedia Commons, Unsplash, and the British Library, which has released 1 million images for public use. By incorporating these images into your original designs, you can reduce the risk of copyright infringement.

Another aspect to consider is the Fair Use Act. This law permits limited and 'transformative' use of copyrighted material for purposes such as commentary, criticism, or parody. However, fair use is often subject to interpretation, and it's important to note that works cannot be copied for commercial use under this act. While you may be able to argue that your use of a copyrighted work is transformative, it's a grey area that could lead to lengthy and costly legal battles.

To further minimize legal risks, it's advisable to create entirely original designs. By expressing your support for a political candidate through your unique artistic creations, you can leverage the protection of the 1st Amendment. This approach ensures that you are not infringing on any copyrights or publicity rights of the candidates. It's worth noting that you should still be cautious not to create an affiliation between yourself and the election group/committee supporting the candidate.

Additionally, it's crucial to respect the right of publicity. Using a politician's name or likeness for commercial purposes without their consent is a violation of their rights. While the 1st Amendment provides some protection for expressive purposes, selling merchandise with their names or images requires their permission. Obtaining consent from the candidates or their committees can help ensure that you are not infringing on their rights and avoiding potential legal repercussions.

Lastly, it's important to be cautious when using images or designs sourced from the internet. While it may seem convenient to use readily available images, they could be protected by copyright laws. Always seek permission from the original creator or copyright owner and be prepared to pay royalties or fees for the rights to use their work. This process can help ensure that you are respecting the intellectual property rights of others while also protecting yourself from legal consequences.

In conclusion, by using original designs, leveraging public domain resources, understanding fair use limitations, respecting publicity rights, and obtaining necessary permissions, you can significantly reduce the risk of copyright issues when selling t-shirts with candidates' names. Remember, it's always advisable to consult with a legal professional for specific guidance on your unique circumstances.

PACs may sell t-shirts with candidates' names and likenesses, treating proceeds as contributions

Political candidates and campaigns have the right of publicity, which means that their name or likeness cannot be used for commercial purposes without their consent. This is especially true in states like Tennessee, the home of Elvis, where the right of publicity is a strong legal protection. However, there are some exceptions to this rule. For example, if you are creating original artwork or designs to support a political candidate, your work may be protected by the First Amendment. It's important to note that this does not give you the right to create a false association with the candidate or their campaign, and you should avoid using their name or likeness to create promotional items without their permission.

In the United States, Political Action Committees (PACs) are allowed to sell t-shirts with the names and likenesses of candidates, treating the proceeds as contributions. This was confirmed by the Federal Election Commission (FEC) in 2019 when they issued an advisory opinion allowing Mad Dog PAC, a nonconnected political committee, to raise funds by selling t-shirts bearing the names and facial likenesses of candidates seeking the Democratic Party's nomination for the 2020 presidential election. The key to this ruling was that the PAC complied with certain requirements, including treating the entire purchase price of the t-shirts as contributions and providing the necessary disclaimers and disclosures to purchasers.

It's important to note that the laws around using someone's name or likeness for commercial purposes can be complex and vary from state to state. Additionally, while the First Amendment may provide some protection for original artwork or designs, it's always best to consult with a lawyer before using someone's name or likeness for commercial purposes, especially when it comes to political candidates.

When creating t-shirts or other merchandise with the names or likenesses of candidates, it's crucial to ensure that any images or designs used are obtained legally and do not infringe on any copyrights or trademarks. This includes ensuring that any photographs or artwork used are in the public domain or that you have the necessary permissions and licenses from the copyright owner. It's also important to be careful with product descriptions and avoid making any direct connections between the candidate and your product, as this could potentially violate their right of publicity.

In summary, while it may be permissible for PACs to sell t-shirts with candidates' names and likenesses under certain conditions, it's important to navigate these legal complexities with caution and seek appropriate legal advice to ensure compliance with applicable laws and regulations.

Frequently asked questions