Burlington Coat Factory: Louis Vuitton Handbags

Does Burlington Coat Factory sell Louis Vuitton handbags? The answer is no, but it's not that simple. In 2005, Louis Vuitton Malletier (LVM) sued Burlington Coat Factory, alleging trademark infringement and counterfeiting. LVM claimed that Burlington was selling beaded handbags with designs and sales codes that evoked LVM's trademarked handbags, causing consumer confusion. The case was decided in favour of LVM, with the court finding that Burlington's bags were likely to create consumer confusion, even without Burlington explicitly establishing its design as a competing mark. While Burlington doesn't sell authentic Louis Vuitton handbags, this case highlights the importance of trademark protection and the potential for consumer confusion in the fashion industry.

Does Burlington sell designer bags?

Burlington, formerly known as Burlington Coat Factory, is an American off-price department store retailer with over 1,000 stores across 40 states and Puerto Rico. The company sells a wide range of products, including clothing, accessories, shoes, and home goods.

While Burlington does sell handbags, there is no clear indication that they are from designer brands. The company's website advertises "handbags & shoes that are too good to pass up" and "handbags starting at $16.99," suggesting that the products are likely not from luxury designers.

Additionally, in an article specifically about luggage at Burlington Coat Factory, the author confirms that the store does not carry handbags. While this article is not a recent source, it is worth noting that it makes a clear distinction between luggage and handbags, indicating that if Burlington sold designer handbags, they would likely be mentioned in this context.

Therefore, while Burlington sells a variety of products, including handbags, there is no strong evidence to suggest that they are from designer brands.

Louis Vuitton vs Burlington Coat Factory Warehouse Corp. lawsuit

In the case of Louis Vuitton Malletier v. Burlington Coat Factory Warehouse Corp., 426 F.3d 532 (2005), the United States Second Circuit Court set a precedent for determining the likelihood of confusion in fashion handbags. The case involved a lawsuit filed by Louis Vuitton Malletier ("LVM") against Burlington Coat Factory ("BCF") and Four Seasons Handbags Company ("Four Seasons") for trademark infringement and counterfeiting.

LVM, a renowned French fashion design company, owns the registered Louis Vuitton Toile Monogram Designs ("Toile marks") and the unregistered Louis Vuitton Monogram Multicolore Designs ("Multicolore mark"). The Multicolore mark, designed by Marc Jacobs and Takashi Murakami, was introduced in 2003 and is based on the Toile marks. LVM's handbags are sold in their stores, through their website, and in select department and specialty retail stores.

In October 2003, BCF, a discount clothing and accessory retailer, began selling a line of beaded handbags under the "Pengyuan" name. These bags featured colourful shapes and the letters "NY" on a white or black background and were priced at $29.98. BCF's buyer, Clare Larson, acknowledged that the design of these bags would remind consumers of LVM's Multicolore bags.

LVM filed a lawsuit in April 2004, claiming trademark infringement, counterfeiting, unfair competition, false designation of origin, trade dress infringement, and trademark dilution under federal and state laws. LVM sought monetary damages and injunctive relief to stop BCF from selling the allegedly infringing handbags.

The district court, Judge Berman, ruled that the BCF and LVM bags conveyed wholly different impressions and were unlikely to confuse consumers. The court denied LVM's motion for a preliminary injunction, stating that significant differences between the handbags were easily discernible, even when viewed from a distance.

The Second Circuit Court, however, disagreed with the district court's application of the Polaroid factors and found that the Lanham Act required analysing the similarity of the products in their purchasing context. The Second Circuit held that the district court erred by focusing on simultaneous viewing of the handbags instead of considering serial viewing, given the market conditions and LVM's claims of initial-interest and post-sale confusion. The Second Circuit vacated the district court's denial of a preliminary injunction and remanded the case for further proceedings.

The Second Circuit's decision to adopt a serial viewing test had a significant impact on the analysis of "likelihood of confusion" in trademark infringement cases. This test requires litigants to conduct extensive consumer studies to gauge confusion under market settings, which can be costly.

Do other retailers sell Louis Vuitton bags?

Louis Vuitton is a French fashion house that was first established in Paris in 1854. The brand has become synonymous with luxury leather goods and cutting-edge clothing. With such a prestigious reputation, it is no surprise that Louis Vuitton products are in high demand and often come with a hefty price tag.

For those who are unable to purchase a brand new Louis Vuitton bag, there are other options available. One way to get your hands on a Louis Vuitton bag is to buy from resale sites. Sites such as eBay, 1st Dibs, The Handbag Clinic, and Luxury Promise offer pre-loved Louis Vuitton bags at discounted prices. These sites provide a great opportunity to find that dream bag at a more affordable cost. It is important to do your research and buy from reputable sites to ensure the authenticity of the product.

In addition to online resale sites, there are physical stores that offer pre-owned Louis Vuitton bags. Sign of the Times, with locations in Chelsea and Berkshire, is one such example. With 45 years of experience in the industry, they offer a rich history and a carefully curated selection of pre-owned luxury items.

Another option for purchasing pre-owned Louis Vuitton bags is through auction houses like Sotheby's. Sotheby's offers free estimates and markets Louis Vuitton items to global buyers in 85 countries. They hold online auctions throughout the year in New York, Europe, and Hong Kong, providing a platform for those seeking a more exclusive buying experience.

While Louis Vuitton products are not typically sold at discounted prices, the resale market provides an opportunity for buyers to find their desired items at more accessible prices. It is worth noting that Louis Vuitton does not have any official outlet stores associated with the brand, so buyers should be cautious of any websites claiming to be authorized outlets.

Do Louis Vuitton bags have a trademark?

Louis Vuitton bags have a number of trademarks. The company registered its first trademark on December 15, 1896, for its iconic monogram canvas, which features the interlocking letters LV and floral motifs. This trademark was created by Louis Vuitton's son, Georges, to ward off counterfeits. The trademarked LV monogram is composed of italicised and capitalised L and V letters, along with diamond, circle, and quatrefoil patterns.

The trademark heat stamp is an embossed Louis Vuitton label found on the outside or inside of a bag or accessory. If inside, the stamp can be found on the lining or, in newer styles, on an interior leather or cloth tag. If outside, it is typically located on the Vachetta trim, detailing, or strap. The stamp should be clear, centred, and have crisp, well-defined letters.

In addition to the trademarked monogram and heat stamp, Louis Vuitton products feature several other key authenticity indicators, including date codes, materials, and craftsmanship. The date code is a combination of two letters and four numbers that indicate where and when the piece was made. These date codes are often accompanied by "factory codes" that correspond to the "made in" stamps on a separate leather piece.

Louis Vuitton is vigilant about monitoring its trademarks and has a history of taking legal action against those who infringe upon them. The company has filed lawsuits against entities producing counterfeit goods or imitating its designs.

Do Louis Vuitton bags have a registered trademark?

Louis Vuitton Malletier, the French fashion design firm, has indeed registered trademarks for its products. The company was founded in 1854 by Louis Vuitton in Paris, France, and is known for its luxury fashion items, particularly its signature monogram canvas.

The distinctive LV monogram, featuring interlocking letters and floral motifs, is a symbol of luxury and has been a registered trademark since December 15, 1896. This trademark was created to protect the brand's unique and recognisable identity and to ward off counterfeits.

Louis Vuitton has been vigilant in monitoring its trademarks and has a history of taking legal action against those who infringe upon them. The company has filed lawsuits against entities producing counterfeit goods or imitating its designs, demonstrating its commitment to protecting its brand identity.

The trademark heat stamp can be found on the outside or inside of a Louis Vuitton bag. If inside, it is usually on the lining or an interior leather or cloth tag. If outside, it can be found on the Vachetta trim, detailing, or strap. The stamp should be clear, centred, and have crisp, well-defined letters.

In addition to the trademark heat stamp, there are other indicators of authenticity for Louis Vuitton bags, including date codes, materials, and craftsmanship. The date code, consisting of two letters and four numbers, indicates where and when the bag was made. The materials used, such as Monogram canvas, Damier canvas, Epi leather, and Monogram Vernis leather, also have specific characteristics that can be used to verify authenticity.

Correct hardware stamps and logos are also important indicators. For example, the Inventeur plaque, a metal trademark stamp, features slightly oblong "O"s rather than round ones, and its machine marks are smooth and neatly finished.

Overall, Louis Vuitton's trademarks and attention to craftsmanship make their products highly valuable and sought-after, with a strong resale market. The company's commitment to protecting its brand through legal action also contributes to maintaining its reputation and exclusivity.

Frequently asked questions