Buttoning Sport Coats: To Button Or Not?

There are differing opinions on whether you should button sports coats when hanging them. Some people believe that you should button them, as that is how they are designed to be worn most of the time. Others believe that you shouldn't button them, as it can put unnecessary strain on the buttons. Some people also believe that the coat will hang better when it is unbuttoned.

Buttoned vs unbuttoned when standing

When it comes to buttoning versus unbuttoning a sports coat while standing, there are a few things to consider. Firstly, the cut of a sports coat is designed to flatter the body when buttoned, creating a visual "V" shape that accentuates the wearer's torso. As such, buttoning a sports coat can help to create a slimming silhouette. Additionally, leaving a sports coat unbuttoned may cause it to hang in a boxy or sloppy manner, which is generally not the desired look when wearing a suit.

On the other hand, some people prefer to leave their sports coats unbuttoned for a more casual look, especially when wearing jeans or in less formal environments. It is also worth noting that buttoning all the buttons on a sports coat can make one appear overly buttoned-up, giving off a "Pee Wee Herman" or "Nutty Professor" vibe. As such, it is generally recommended to only button the top button on a two-button sports coat, or the top and middle buttons on a three-button coat, leaving the bottom button open.

Ultimately, the decision to button or unbutton a sports coat while standing is a matter of personal preference and comfort. However, it is worth considering the occasion and desired look when making this decision, as buttoning a sports coat can help to create a more polished and put-together appearance.

Buttoned vs unbuttoned when sitting

When it comes to buttoning vs unbuttoning a sport coat while sitting, there are a few things to consider. Firstly, it is generally recommended to unbutton your coat while sitting down as it can help to reduce the strain on the buttons and the coat itself. This is especially important if you are using a standard hanger, as it will help to maintain the natural shape of the coat. Leaving a buttoned sport coat on a hanger can cause it to sag and stretch over time, rendering it unwearable.

However, it is worth noting that some people prefer to keep their sport coats buttoned while hanging, particularly if they are using a suit hanger that emulates the natural curve of the shoulders. This can help to maintain the structure and shape of the coat. Additionally, it is common for people to unbutton their sport coats while walking, even if they choose to button them while standing still. Ultimately, the decision to button or unbutton a sport coat while sitting or hanging comes down to personal preference and comfort.

When wearing a sport coat, the general rule is to button it when standing and unbutton it when sitting. This helps to create a flattering silhouette and accentuates the "V" shape of the torso. Unbuttoning the coat while sitting can also prevent bunching and wrinkling in the lap and reduce pressure on the buttons from the slight expansion of the abdomen when seated. It is recommended to only button the top button on a two-button sport coat and to button the top and middle buttons, leaving the bottom one open, on a three-button coat.

It is worth noting that there are some exceptions to the buttoning rules. For instance, wearers of low-roll, preppy-style three-button jackets usually fasten only the middle button, while two-button wearers typically close only the top. Additionally, double-breasted jackets are never unbuttoned. Leaving the bottom button unbuttoned on a three-button jacket can also give a more relaxed and casual appearance. Ultimately, you can choose to button or unbutton your sport coat depending on your personal preference and the level of formality you want to achieve.

Buttoned vs unbuttoned when hanging in storage

When hanging a sport coat in storage, there are a few schools of thought on whether it should be buttoned or unbuttoned. Some people believe that the coat should be buttoned to emulate the natural curve of the shoulders. However, others argue that it is unnecessary to put strain on the buttons and that a proper hanger will keep the shoulder shape without needing to button the coat.

Leaving a sport coat unbuttoned when hanging can help to prevent unnecessary strain on the buttons. Over time, buttons can become strained or damaged if the coat is constantly kept buttoned when not being worn. Additionally, the coat may sag and stretch if left buttoned, potentially rendering it unwearable.

On the other hand, buttoning a sport coat when hanging can help to maintain its shape, particularly at the shoulders. Sport coats are designed to be worn buttoned most of the time, and hanging them in this way can help to emulate the natural curve of the shoulders.

Ultimately, the decision of whether to button or unbutton a sport coat when hanging in storage is a matter of personal preference. Some people prefer to keep their coats buttoned to maintain their shape, while others prefer to unbutton them to avoid putting strain on the buttons. Whichever option is chosen, using a proper hanger is essential to support the shoulders and prevent the coat from sagging.

Buttoned vs unbuttoned with jeans

When it comes to buttoned vs unbuttoned sports coats with jeans, there are a few things to consider. Firstly, it is generally accepted that sports coats can be worn with jeans, but it is important to ensure that the jeans are in excellent condition and paired with a sleek, neutral-coloured belt.

Now, onto the buttoning. The general rule for buttoning a sports coat is to button when standing and unbutton when sitting. This is to ensure the coat fits properly when standing and to avoid creases when sitting. However, this rule is not set in stone, and some people choose to unbutton their sports coats when walking or standing as well. Ultimately, it is a matter of personal preference.

When it comes to the number of buttons, a sports coat will typically have two or three. For a two-button sports coat, only the top button should be fastened, while the bottom button is left undone. For a three-button sports coat, the top button is optional, the middle button is always fastened, and the bottom button is never fastened.

It is worth noting that the rules for buttoning a sports coat are more relaxed than those for a suit jacket, as sports coats are considered more casual. Additionally, the cut of the sports coat will also determine how it should be buttoned. If the sports coat is too tight and barely buttons up, it is too small.

So, should you button or unbutton your sports coat when wearing it with jeans? The choice is yours! You can choose to follow the general rule of buttoning when standing and unbuttoning when sitting, or you can go for a more casual look by leaving it unbuttoned. Just remember to avoid creases and ensure your jeans and belt are in good condition.

Buttoned vs unbuttoned with slacks

When it comes to buttoning or unbuttoning your sport coat with slacks, there are a few factors to consider. Firstly, it is generally recommended to button your jacket while standing and unbutton it while sitting down. This is because the cut of the suit is designed to flatter the body when buttoned, creating a visual "V" shape that accentuates your torso. Unbuttoning the jacket can make it look boxy and sloppy. However, you may want to unbutton while walking or if you have a larger midsection, as buttoning the jacket can add bulk.

If your sport coat has two buttons, only the top button should be buttoned. For a three-button sport coat, button the top two and leave the bottom one unbuttoned. It is also worth noting that you should avoid wearing a dirty or wrinkled sport coat, as it can take away from the overall aesthetic.

When pairing your sport coat with slacks, it is important to create a balanced and streamlined look. The slacks should be chosen to complement the colour and pattern of the sport coat. For example, if the sport coat is patterned, opt for neutral-coloured slacks in shades like beige, grey, or cream. Additionally, the fit of the slacks should be considered. Well-fitting slacks that are not too tight or too loose will create a polished silhouette.

In terms of footwear, the choice of shoes can either complement or detract from the overall outfit. For a more elegant and relaxed appearance, loafers, Oxfords, or casual brogues pair well with slacks. Including accessories such as a pocket square or a stylish belt can also enhance the overall aesthetic of the outfit.

Frequently asked questions