The 'Where Is Peng Shuai?' T-Shirt: A Powerful Message

The 'Where is Peng Shuai' T-shirts were worn by supporters of the Chinese tennis player at the Australian Open in 2022. Peng Shuai had disappeared from public view for three weeks after accusing a senior Chinese politician of rape in a post on Chinese social media platform Weibo. Following the controversy, spectators at the Australian Open were asked to remove their shirts, which referenced the tennis player, as they were deemed to be political. However, after international backlash, the ban on the T-shirts was reversed.

The Australian Open's initial ban on the t-shirts

The Australian Open initially banned spectators from wearing "Where is Peng Shuai?" T-shirts, confiscating them on the grounds that they were "political" and "commercial." This decision sparked widespread backlash, with critics accusing Tennis Australia of censorship and prioritizing sponsorship deals with Chinese companies over human rights.

The controversy began when security and police at Melbourne Park ordered two spectators to remove their "Where is Peng Shuai?" T-shirts and a banner. Tennis Australia defended their decision, stating that they don't allow "clothing, banners, or signs that are commercial or political" per their ticket conditions of entry. They also asserted that Peng Shuai's safety was their "primary concern."

However, the ban faced strong opposition from human rights activists, tennis players, and high-profile figures. Martina Navratilova, a former world number one tennis player, called the decision "pathetic" on Twitter. French tennis player Nicolas Mahut also criticized the organizers, suggesting that they were bowing to pressure from Chinese sponsors. Australian Defense Minister Peter Dutton weighed in, stating that Peng Shuai's case was "not a political issue" but a "human rights issue."

Facing mounting pressure, Tennis Australia eventually overturned the ban, allowing spectators to wear the T-shirts as long as they remained peaceful and did not cause any disruptions. This decision was welcomed by activists, who had planned to wear the T-shirts again and distribute 1,000 more at Melbourne Park.

The subsequent reversal of the ban

The "Where is Peng Shuai?" T-shirt ban at the Australian Open was reversed after a global outcry. The initial ban was met with fierce criticism from human rights groups and the international tennis community, with some suggesting that organisers were bowing to pressure from major Chinese corporate sponsors.

Tennis Australia, the organising body behind the Australian Open, said Peng Shuai's safety remained their "primary concern". They had previously defended their decision to confiscate the T-shirts and banners, stating that they had a longstanding policy of not allowing banners, signs or clothing that are commercial or political.

However, following the backlash, Craig Tiley, chief executive of Tennis Australia, announced that they would allow spectators to wear the T-shirts as long as they attended without the "intent to disrupt" and were "peaceful". He added that banners would still not be allowed as "it really takes away from the comfort and safety of the fans".

The decision to reverse the ban was welcomed by human rights activists, with Max Mok, a human rights activist, saying, "Let's hope Tennis Australia keep to their promise and let the crowd wear them." Drew Pavlou, who was behind the GoFundMe campaign to print the T-shirts, also praised the news, claiming that Tennis Australia had initially confiscated the T-shirts due to their large sponsorship deals with Chinese companies.

Martina Navratilova's criticism of the ban

Tennis legend Martina Navratilova criticised the ban on 'Where is Peng Shuai?' t-shirts at the Australian Open, calling the decision "pathetic" and "cowardly". In a tweet, Navratilova wrote, "That's just pathetic. The @wta stands pretty much alone on this!!! #WhereisPengShuai". She further emphasised that the issue was not a political statement but a human rights statement, expressing disappointment that the Australian Open was "letting China dictate what they do at their own slam".

Navratilova's comments came in response to video footage that emerged of security officials and police telling fans to remove the t-shirts. Tournament organisers defended the move, citing a ticket policy that prohibited political clothing. However, Navratilova, who has won 59 Grand Slam titles, argued that the Women's Tennis Association (WTA) had been strong on the issue, while other organisations had been weak. She specifically mentioned the ATP and the IOC as examples of those not taking a firm stance.

Navratilova also questioned the motivation behind the ban, suggesting that the Australian Open organisers were prioritising sponsorship money from China over human rights concerns. She praised the WTA for demanding to hear directly from Peng Shuai and for suspending tournaments in China. The former doubles world number one's safety and well-being were a primary concern for Navratilova and other leading players at the Australian Open, who wanted to ensure she was truly free and not under any coercion.

The backlash against the ban led to the Australian Open reversing its decision less than 24 hours after defending it. Tournament director Craig Tiley clarified that the issue was not with the t-shirts but with the intent to disrupt the tournament. He stated that fans were welcome to wear the "Where is Peng Shuai?" t-shirts as long as they did not bring banners or intend to disrupt the event.

The t-shirts' message and intent

The "Where is Peng Shuai?" T-shirts were created to raise awareness about the disappearance of the Chinese tennis player, Peng Shuai, after she accused a top Chinese official, former vice-premier Zhang Gaoli, of sexual misconduct in a post on Chinese social media platform Weibo in November 2021. The post was quickly deleted, and Peng Shuai was absent from public view for three weeks, sparking global concern for her safety and wellbeing.

The T-shirts were initially banned by Tennis Australia, the organising body behind the Australian Open, which stated that it does not "allow clothing, banners or signs that are commercial or political" at the tournament. This decision faced widespread backlash and criticism, including from prominent figures such as tennis legend Martina Navratilova, who called the decision "pathetic", and Australian Defence Minister Peter Dutton, who said that Peng Shuai's case was "not a political issue" but a "human rights issue".

The T-shirts featured the words "Where is Peng Shuai?" along with a photo of her face and the word "wanted". They were designed to be a form of advocacy and a way to show support for Peng Shuai, calling attention to her disappearance and demanding answers about her whereabouts and wellbeing. The message intended to express concern for her safety and well-being and to seek more clarity on her situation.

Following the backlash, Tennis Australia eventually reversed its ban on the T-shirts, with a spokesperson stating that they would take a "common-sense approach" to ticketing conditions and allow certain messaging as long as there was no disruption to the event. This decision was welcomed by human rights activists, who saw it as a victory for freedom of speech and a step towards prioritising human rights over commercial interests.

The GoFundMe campaign to print more t-shirts

The GoFundMe campaign to print more "Where is Peng Shuai?" T-shirts was launched in response to the confiscation of similar T-shirts and banners at the Australian Open in 2022. The campaign aimed to raise AUD$10,000 to print 1,000 T-shirts to be handed out for free at Melbourne Park before the women's final.

The T-shirts and banners were created to show support for Chinese tennis player Peng Shuai, who had disappeared from public view for three weeks after accusing a top Chinese official of sexual misconduct in November 2021. Peng's wellbeing became a matter of international concern among the tennis community and human rights groups.

Tennis Australia, the organising body behind the Australian Open, initially confiscated the T-shirts and banners, deeming them "political" and stating that they were not allowed under their ticket conditions of entry. This decision sparked backlash, with critics accusing Tennis Australia of prioritizing sponsorship deals with Chinese companies over human rights.

In response to the criticism, Tennis Australia reversed its ban on the T-shirts, stating that they would now allow certain messaging as long as there was no disruption to the event. The GoFundMe campaign ultimately raised over $15,000, and the T-shirts were worn by supporters at the Australian Open.

Frequently asked questions