Nice Guy Eddie's Killer: A T-Shirt Mystery

In the 1992 film Reservoir Dogs, written and directed by Quentin Tarantino, there is a famous Mexican standoff scene in which most of the characters die. One character, Nice Guy Eddie, played by Chris Penn, is seen dead on the ground at the end of the scene, but it is unclear who shot him. In the script, it is Mr. White who shoots Eddie, but in the film, Mr. White shoots Eddie's father, Joe Cabot, and then falls to the ground himself before he is able to shoot Eddie. There are several fan theories about who ultimately killed Nice Guy Eddie, with some speculating that it was Mr. Pink, who was hiding under a ramp, or that it was Mr. Orange, or even that Eddie was not shot at all.

Mr. White shoots Nice Guy Eddie

In the 1992 film Reservoir Dogs, written and directed by Quentin Tarantino, the character Nice Guy Eddie Cabot, played by Chris Penn, is killed in a Mexican standoff. During the standoff, Joe Cabot (Lawrence Tierney) arrives at the warehouse and, suspecting Mr. Orange (Tim Roth) of being a traitor, is about to kill him. Mr. White (Harvey Keitel) intervenes and holds Joe at gunpoint, who in turn points his gun at Mr. Orange. Eddie then aims at Mr. White, threatening to kill him if he hurts his father. The three fire their weapons, and Joe and Eddie Cabot die, while Mr. White and Mr. Orange are injured.

However, a mistake in the scene reveals that Eddie died before Mr. White fired at him. Chris Penn explained that his blood squib, a mini explosive device used to simulate gunfire, went off earlier than planned, causing him to fall to the floor prematurely. While the script intended for Mr. White to shoot and kill Eddie, the premature activation of the squib on Keitel's gun caused it to go off immediately after shooting Tierney, resulting in Penn's character falling before being shot. Despite this error, Tarantino decided to keep the scene as he believed it would create controversy and generate discussion about the film.

This mistake sparked various fan theories about who ultimately shot and killed Nice Guy Eddie. Some viewers speculate that Mr. Pink, played by Steve Buscemi, shot Eddie from under the ramp where Mr. Orange was hiding. They base this theory on the fact that Eddie was shot in the head and mouth from two different angles, which Mr. White could not have achieved from his position. Others maintain that Mr. White was responsible for Eddie's death, as evidenced by the script and the discharge of his weapon seen in slow-motion replays.

Regardless of the discrepancy, it is clear that Nice Guy Eddie did not survive the shooting. The film's ending leaves Mr. White as the last man standing, who shoots Mr. Orange before being killed by the police.

Mr. Pink shoots Nice Guy Eddie

In the 1992 film Reservoir Dogs, written and directed by Quentin Tarantino, the character Nice Guy Eddie, played by Chris Penn, is killed in a Mexican standoff. However, there is a continuity error in the scene, as Eddie falls to the ground before he is shot by any of the other characters.

In the scene, Mr. White (Harvey Keitel) shoots Joe Cabot (Lawrence Tierney), and Mr. Orange (Tim Roth) shoots Mr. White. Eddie also shoots Mr. White, but falls to the ground before either of them shoot him. Mr. Pink (Steve Buscemi) is hidden under a ramp during the shootout, and emerges after the other characters have fallen.

There are several fan theories about who shot Nice Guy Eddie. Some fans believe that Mr. White shot Eddie, as he was the only character with a gun who was not shot himself. However, others have pointed out that Mr. White only fired one shot, at Joe Cabot. Some fans have also suggested that Mr. Pink shot Eddie, as he is seen with a gun in his hand after the shootout, and Eddie was shot in the head and mouth, which would not have been possible from Mr. White's position.

Ultimately, the scene as it was filmed does not definitively show who shot Nice Guy Eddie, and the continuity error has been the subject of much discussion and analysis by fans of the film.

No one shoots Nice Guy Eddie

In the 1992 film Reservoir Dogs, written and directed by Quentin Tarantino, there is a climactic Mexican standoff between three of the remaining six characters: Mr. White (Harvey Keitel), Joe Cabot (Lawrence Tierney), and Joe's son, Nice Guy Eddie Cabot (Chris Penn). In the scene, Joe arrives at the warehouse, intending to kill Mr. Orange (Tim Roth), whom he suspects of being an undercover cop. Mr. White intervenes, holding Joe at gunpoint, and Nice Guy Eddie, in turn, aims at Mr. White, demanding that he drops his gun. The three fire their weapons, and Joe and Nice Guy Eddie die, while Mr. White and Mr. Orange are injured.

However, a close examination of the scene reveals that Nice Guy Eddie fell to the floor before he was shot by Mr. White. This was due to a mistake with the timing of the blood squibs, miniature explosive devices used to simulate gunfire. According to actor Chris Penn, Mr. White was supposed to shoot Joe and then Nice Guy Eddie, but Mr. White's blood squib accidentally went off early, causing the actor to fall to the floor before firing at Nice Guy Eddie. Despite this error, Tarantino decided to keep the scene as he believed it would create controversy and give audiences something to discuss.

While no one shoots Nice Guy Eddie in the film, the script indicates that Mr. White was intended to be the one to shoot him. This rules out the possibility of Mr. Orange shooting Nice Guy Eddie, as he is shot by Joe. Some fan theories have speculated that another character, Mr. Pink, may have shot Nice Guy Eddie, but this is not supported by the film or the script.

Nice Guy Eddie's death in the film, therefore, stands as an intriguing anomaly, adding to the complex web of betrayal and violence that unfolds in the final act of Reservoir Dogs.

Eddie dies before Mr. White fires at him

In the 1992 film Reservoir Dogs, directed by Quentin Tarantino, there is a Mexican standoff between Mr. White (Harvey Keitel), Joe Cabot (Lawrence Tierney), and Nice Guy Eddie (Chris Penn). In this scene, Mr. White intervenes to protect Mr. Orange (Tim Roth) from Joe, who suspects Mr. Orange of being the undercover cop in their group of thieves. Mr. White holds Joe at gunpoint, and Eddie, in turn, aims at Mr. White, threatening to kill him if he hurts his father. The three men then fire their weapons, resulting in the deaths of Joe and Eddie, and injuries to Mr. White and Mr. Orange.

However, a notable mistake occurs in this scene. Upon close inspection, it is evident that Eddie dies before Mr. White fires at him. Chris Penn, the actor playing Eddie, explained that his blood squib, a miniature explosive device used to simulate gunfire, accidentally detonated prematurely, causing him to fall before he was shot. This error prompted Tarantino to keep the scene as is, believing that it would generate discussion and intrigue among viewers.

The inclusion of this mistake has indeed sparked conversations and analyses of the film. Some viewers have suggested that Mr. Pink, who was hiding during the standoff, could have shot Eddie. However, this theory is refuted by others who argue that Mr. Pink had no motive to shoot any of the men and that the angle of Mr. White's shot clearly indicates that he fired the fatal shot.

Despite the error, the scene remains a pivotal moment in the film, and the ultimate outcome is unchanged: Eddie does not survive the shooting. The mistake serves as an intriguing detail for audiences to dissect, adding to the film's enduring appeal and cult status.

Eddie shoots Mr. White twice

In the final scene of Quentin Tarantino's 1992 film Reservoir Dogs, a Mexican standoff takes place between Mr. White (Harvey Keitel), Joe Cabot (Lawrence Tierney), and Joe's son, "Nice Guy" Eddie Cabot (Chris Penn). The scene is riddled with mistakes, one of which left a big question: who shot Eddie?

In the scene, Joe arrives at the warehouse, intending to kill Mr. Orange (Tim Roth), whom he suspects is the traitor who set them up. Mr. White intervenes, holding Joe at gunpoint while demanding that Joe puts his gun down. Eddie then aims at Mr. White, threatening to kill him if he hurts his father. The three fire their weapons, with Joe and Eddie dying, and Mr. White and Mr. Orange injured. However, upon closer inspection, it becomes clear that Eddie died before Mr. White fired at him.

Chris Penn explained that his blood squib, a mini explosive device used to simulate gunfire, went off earlier than planned, causing him to fall to the floor prematurely. As a result, Mr. White's actor, Harvey Keitel, accidentally shot Lawrence Tierney, who played Joe Cabot, before turning to shoot Penn, but Penn's squib had already gone off. Despite this mistake, director Tarantino decided to keep the scene as he believed it would create controversy and give audiences something to discuss.

In the script, it is Mr. White who shoots Eddie, and some viewers have pointed out that they can hear Mr. White's weapon discharge twice in slow motion. However, this scene was not intended to be replayed in slow motion, and the timing of the squibs and Eddie's fall created a minor discrepancy.

Frequently asked questions